A company must choose between two projects because it lacks the resources to run both simultaneously. Both projects require 12 months to complete and cost $250,000 each. The company’s decision is to be based on a 3-year forecast of financial benefits following the projects’ completion.
Project 1 – Process Optimization:
- Expected cost reduction of $300,000 per year.
- The savings begin in the first year after project completion and continue identically each year for the following two years.
Project 2 – New Product Development:
- Generates incremental income during the project:
- First 6 months: $15,000
- Second 6 months: $55,000
- After the project is finished, it produces income over the next 3 years as follows:
- 1st year: $230,000
- 2nd year: $300,000
- 3rd year: $300,000
Based on the financial projections over the 3-year period after project completion, which project is more attractive?